Flatbush, Brooklyn

The Move to Flatbush

Flatbush in the late 19th century was transitioning from a village on Brooklyn's outskirts to a built-up urban neighbourhood served by the newly extended street railways. Irish families who had spent a generation in the waterfront districts of Red Hook, Carroll Gardens, and South Brooklyn — working the docks, building the infrastructure, establishing their communities around the Catholic parish network — made the move to Flatbush as their economic circumstances improved.

The pattern was consistent: first-generation dockers and domestic servants living in the dense streets near the Brooklyn waterfront; second generation moving to the slightly better housing of Park Slope or Cobble Hill; third generation arriving in Flatbush with a steady civil service salary, children in the parish school, and ambitions for the American Dream that seemed entirely achievable from a two-family house on a tree-lined block.

The Cork and Galway contingents were particularly strong in Flatbush. Cork families — reflecting that county's long maritime connection to the ports of the eastern seaboard — had established footholds in Brooklyn from the earliest period of mass Irish immigration, and the Flatbush community drew on this continuous chain. Galway families, predominantly from the western seaboard, followed the same pattern: arrival at the docks, settlement in the waterfront parishes, then movement toward Flatbush as the second and third generations sought better housing.

The Dodgers, the Parish, and Brooklyn Irish Identity

The Brooklyn Dodgers at Ebbets Field — located in Flatbush, at the corner of Sullivan Place and McKeever Place — were the tribal totem of the Brooklyn Irish community as much as of any other group. The Dodgers were a working-class team in a working-class borough, and Irish families from Flatbush to Bay Ridge followed them with the intensity that their forebears had brought to GAA county matches in Clare or Cork.

The connection between Irish-American identity and the Dodgers is well-documented in the oral histories of Brooklyn Irish families. When the Dodgers moved to Los Angeles in 1957, the departure was experienced as a kind of second diaspora by the community that had made Ebbets Field a neighbourhood institution — and the timing was almost perfectly aligned with the beginning of the Irish dispersal from Flatbush itself.

Holy Cross Roman Catholic Church on Church Avenue was the parish anchor for the Irish community of central Flatbush. The school attached to the church educated multiple generations of Irish-Brooklyn children, and the parish's social life — the sodalities, the sports clubs, the annual rounds of fundraising and celebration — structured community time in the way that Gaelic Ireland had structured it around the church calendar, translated into American conditions.

The Long Goodbye

The dispersal from Flatbush followed the same pattern as other outer-borough Irish neighbourhoods: the postwar availability of Veterans Administration mortgages, the construction of Long Island suburbs, and the gradual transformation of the neighbourhood toward a predominantly Caribbean character from the 1960s onward. The Irish families who had built Flatbush did not leave suddenly — they left over twenty years, each family making its individual calculation about when the time had come to join the relative in Nassau County or Westchester.

By 1975, the Irish-American character of Flatbush was historical rather than demographic. The parish institutions persisted, the parish records remained, and the architectural character of the neighbourhood — the detached and semi-detached houses, the tree canopy, the quiet residential streets — was unchanged. But the population was different.

For genealogists, Flatbush's Irish era is well-documented. The Diocese of Brooklyn Archives holds Holy Cross parish records and those of the smaller parishes in the district. US Census records from 1900 through 1960 capture the Irish-American demographic in detail. The Kings County Clerk holds naturalization records, probate files, and property records for the families who owned homes here. Flatbush is one of the most fully documented Irish-American settlement areas in Brooklyn.

Frequently Asked Questions